Suggestion for new type of ammo testing

Started by Intercooler, June 22 2012 10:28:52 AM MDT

Previous topic - Next topic

Intercooler

    If I get to the range at the right times I can sneak in some off-topic type of testing. I have plenty of HP's and was thinking about doing water jug tests since the pool of ammo for Chronographing is about at the end. I'm open to something with easy setup that may tell us how these perform.

sqlbullet

I did some water jug testing with 205 grain WFN a year or so ago.  From my Elite Match my handloads went through eleven gallon milk jugs.  That was all that would fit on the table.  Bullet was not recovered.

That lead me to conclude that I needed a denser medium to test my that particular load.  It is my black bear defense load for the mountains.  I don't have the data in front of me, but I believe it was 12.5 grains of #9 with a CCI 300 primer.

I have been thinking about using some plastic bins from big lots or all-a-dollar that I can fill with newspaper, put in the suburban and then top off with water the night before.  Then when I get to the shooting area, just pull them out and shoot.

Intercooler

11 empty right? In watching videos I rarely see any ammo tested with water jugs pass through more than 5. One video of a .500 Magnum may have topped 7.

sqlbullet

11 full of water.

Keep in mind this is not a hollow point round.  The exit hole in the eleventh jug showed the slug had not expanded at all.

And yes, I was shocked as all get out.  I never would have thought it would make it through them all.  I had witnesses who were equally surprised.

Maybe our water hear in mountains is less dense.

Intercooler

Firing into a log and recovering... what is that like?

sqlbullet

I haven't done that for years.  Recovery is a real pain to accomplish without wrecking the slug because it doesn't usually follow a straight path.

uz2bUSMC

Quote from: Intercooler on June 22 2012 10:28:52 AM MDT
    If I get to the range at the right times I can sneak in some off-topic type of testing. I have plenty of HP's and was thinking about doing water jug tests since the pool of ammo for Chronographing is about at the end. I'm open to something with easy setup that may tell us how these perform.

Well, I don't know what kind of freedom you have at your range or how much you want to spend but... I've done some testing on pork shoulders and it's fairly informative.

Turn this

into this
10mm enthusiast since '98.

When you have hits on target with your feet moving, you're a shooter... all else is target practice.

REDLINE

Gun Control?  Oh yes, the theory that becoming a victim is somehow morally superior to defending yourself & your family.  Makes perfect sense.

sqlbullet

i like shooting watermelons to teach gun safety to small children.  buy it a few days ahead.  have an activity were they decorate them and name them.  then they get a little attached and you have them shoot it with a 22mag.

that helps them understand the permanence of a gunshot wound.

Intercooler

Does anyone follow tnoutdoors9 on YouTube? I have bugged him about doing testing with 10mm and offered to donate ammo. He recently bought a .357 GP100 and started doing those tests. In one of his videos he said 10mm testing by the end of 2012! He uses ballistics gel and his videos and results are top notch. I may just wait to see what he does... he isn't familiar with Underwood Ammo right now.

The_Shadow

The meat testing I do is when I actually get to shoot animals while hunting!  Even then meat is too expensive to waste!
The "10mm" I'm Packin', Has The Bullets Wackin', Smakin' & The Slide is Rackin' & Jackin'!
NRA Life Member
Southeast, LoUiSiAna

uz2bUSMC

Quote from: The_Shadow on June 28 2012 10:38:32 AM MDT
The meat testing I do is when I actually get to shoot animals while hunting!  Even then meat is too expensive to waste!

It was a sad day but the pork shoulder was more cooperative than live animals.
10mm enthusiast since '98.

When you have hits on target with your feet moving, you're a shooter... all else is target practice.

Vice

Quote from: sqlbullet on June 27 2012 07:54:41 PM MDT
i like shooting watermelons to teach gun safety to small children.  buy it a few days ahead.  have an activity were they decorate them and name them.  then they get a little attached and you have them shoot it with a 22mag.

that helps them understand the permanence of a gunshot wound.

+1

What really struck home with me growing up, but very difficult to do these days, shooting wrecked cars.  I was amazed as a kid the damage a bullet could do to various parts of an automobile.

REDLINE

Maybe I'm just too much of a blend of common sense and realism, just odd to me Gun Safety needs to be taught.  And clearly it does NEED to be taught for many.

I mean, isn't the sound of round being touched off while not wearing hearing protection enough to strongly suggest;  Hey, maybe I shouldn't point that thing in any direction I wouldn't want a bullet headed toward.  Nevermind me, just have a hard time understanding carelessness and ignorance.
Gun Control?  Oh yes, the theory that becoming a victim is somehow morally superior to defending yourself & your family.  Makes perfect sense.

sqlbullet

Quote from: REDLINE on June 29 2012 03:35:43 PM MDT
Maybe I'm just too much of a blend of common sense and realism, just odd to me Gun Safety needs to be taught.  And clearly it does NEED to be taught for many.

I mean, isn't the sound of round being touched off while not wearing hearing protection enough to strongly suggest;  Hey, maybe I shouldn't point that thing in any direction I wouldn't want a bullet headed toward.  Nevermind me, just have a hard time understanding carelessness and ignorance.

Keep in mind I am teaching a then 4 and 5 year old on the young side.  The 8 and up crowd are pretty solid.