Compact 10mm

Reverendpdp · January 19 2015 09:11:10 AM MST

Hello to all.
I am pretty certain that a 10mm is in my future, but I haven't decided which model yet. I'd like a compact model and haven't ruled out the RIA Ultra MS, the Glock 20, or the Witness P Compact. The gun will not be my primary CCW, but will be carried in the woods as a backup... so it needs to be light. Can you give me some opinions?

sqlbullet · January 19 2015 10:18:49 AM MST

I am a long way from a Glock fanboi. But, given your requirements, about the only solid choice is a Glock 29.

Witness compacts are still pretty heavy as steel guns. Even the polymer Witness has 1/4 lb on the Glock 29. Add in the fact that you may need to tune it up a bit before it runs 100%.

That said, you list a Glock 20 on your list. That is a long way from a "compact" gun in my book. So, I may be confused about your requirements.

MCQUADE · January 19 2015 10:21:01 AM MST

Yep, I second a Glock 29 for your needs. I am no Glock fanboy either.

Rockyd · January 19 2015 12:19:19 PM MST

G29sf is my EDC. I use to carry a G20 on the job and off. I didn't think that it was that heavy back then. My 29 is so light that I have to do an arm check to make sure that I didn't forget to put it on. You can drop in an extended barrel and G20 mag and you have it all. I do still carry my 20 at times but it is because it was with me for so many years, that I just want to take my old friend out for a walk! ${$default_grin_smiley}$

Reverendpdp · January 19 2015 12:20:43 PM MST

Quote from: sqlbullet on January 19 2015 10:18:49 AM MST
I am a long way from a Glock fanboi. But, given your requirements, about the only solid choice is a Glock 29.

Witness compacts are still pretty heavy as steel guns. Even the polymer Witness has 1/4 lb on the Glock 29. Add in the fact that you may need to tune it up a bit before it runs 100%.

That said, you list a Glock 20 on your list. That is a long way from a "compact" gun in my book. So, I may be confused about your requirements.

Sorry I meant the Glock 29... got confused with the models.

ShadeTreeVTX · January 19 2015 03:08:37 PM MST

Yup - G29sf fits the bill perfectly. Like this one.

Doug

DeltaSteve · January 19 2015 03:54:40 PM MST

My Glock 29 runs like a Top ${$default_kiss_smiley}$ , the recoil compared to others is very manageable, the wife loves it.

sqlbullet · January 19 2015 04:02:36 PM MST

Quote from: DeltaSteve on January 19 2015 03:54:40 PM MST
My Glock 29 runs like a Top ${$default_kiss_smiley}$ , the recoil compared to others is very manageable, the wife loves it.

I will second this. My Glock 29 shoots about like my Para p16-40/10mm and my Witness full size in 10mm. Perceived recoil is subjective, but I perceive it about the same.

10mmfan · January 20 2015 12:18:55 PM MST

I would go with the glock if you want a true compact due to the eaa compacts mag. If you are ok with a normal grip but short slide check out the witness P carry.

Dave84 · January 22 2015 05:44:23 PM MST

Glock 29 is the only 100 % reliable option. I love mine and carry it often.

Osageid · January 22 2015 05:46:28 PM MST

Another 29 vote here.

cwall64 · January 22 2015 09:35:07 PM MST

Love my G29, just received my Crossbreed IWB holster Tuesday.

DeltaSteve · January 23 2015 08:36:50 AM MST

Here's mine, +2 extension makes for a stable grip just right . Sucky iPhone pic..... ${$default_angry_smiley}$

Dave84 · January 23 2015 07:49:32 PM MST

Which +2 is that? I tried the pearce and the Arredondo +5 and they messed with reliability. Is it 100%?

billlyb · February 01 2015 05:51:13 PM MST

Quote from: DeltaSteve on January 23 2015 08:36:50 AM MST
Here's mine, +2 extension makes for a stable grip just right . Sucky iPhone pic..... ${$default_angry_smiley}$

hi where did you find the plus 2 for the g29 I cant seem to find one thanks.