Ruger and S&W 10mm revolvers

Started by Longcarbine, April 29 2021 10:46:02 AM MDT

Previous topic - Next topic

Longcarbine

Did not want to hijack Rick R's post on the Ruger 10mm. I have purchased a Ruger GP100 a 10mm Blackhawk and a S&W 610 within the last couple of months. The GP100 had decent accuracy and probably could have been better were it not for the horrible trigger, very rough and close to 5 lb's in single action, it has since left the stable. The S&W on the other hand is like driving a Cadillac, single action trigger just at 3 lb's and everything smooth as greased owl s**t on a doorknob. The Blackhawk is showing great promise and with a little tweaking should be fine hunter. Here are some expansion test I did on a few different bullets with the S&W, these were on gallon water jugs at 25 yards. All bullets were loaded over 9gn's of Longshot, didn't have a crony at the time so no velocity info. This is my first post so Howdy! and thanks for letting me in.



"The reason a dog has so many friends,He wags his tail instead of his tongue."

"I don't always listen to Black Sabbath,But when I do so do the neighbors."

CtYankee

Yes, Ruger can have mediocre triggers, especially the newer ones. my GP100 10mm was a little rough, but it was fixable. About $35 for springs and shims and a couple hours of bench time polishing parts and installing said springs and shims and the trigger is just fine.

sparkyv

Howdy.  Good results on the expansion tests for the first three bullets. I'm a huge M610 fan.
sparkyv
NRA Life Member

Longcarbine

Quote from: sparkyv on April 29 2021 06:38:15 PM MDT
Howdy.  Good results on the expansion tests for the first three bullets. I'm a huge M610 fan.
I believe those Everglade bullets were designed for the .40 caliber, 10mm velocity is a bit much for them. I prefer the Federal HST's for 10mm.
"The reason a dog has so many friends,He wags his tail instead of his tongue."

"I don't always listen to Black Sabbath,But when I do so do the neighbors."

gnappi

Since Ruger dropped the Security six fire control group for the GP style I haven't bought a Ruger. Nothing beats a S&W. Good luck with yours.

Regards,

    Gary

TXCOONDOG

It's been a real struggle with a debate of to get a 10 revolver. Just something about being an auto loader cartridge :o

sparkyv

I wasn't sure I'd like the moonclips either, but being able to shoot 40S&W was a boon, and I quickly adapted to the moonclips.  The M610 is a real honey!
Quote from: TXCOONDOG on March 13 2022 06:11:15 PM MDT
It's been a real struggle with a debate of to get a 10 revolver. Just something about being an auto loader cartridge :o
sparkyv
NRA Life Member

TXCOONDOG

Quote from: sparkyv on March 29 2022 01:14:51 PM MDT
I wasn't sure I'd like the moonclips either, but being able to shoot 40S&W was a boon, and I quickly adapted to the moonclips.  The M610 is a real honey!
Quote from: TXCOONDOG on March 13 2022 06:11:15 PM MDT
It's been a real struggle with a debate of to get a 10 revolver. Just something about being an auto loader cartridge :o

Actually I like the idea of moon clips as it will be faster than a speed loader and keeps the fired brass together. I think the 10mm is perfect for a auto.  Every time I get ready to buy a 10mm revolver, I start considering the 41 mag and 44 mag and how much they offer in versatility (mild to wild).


Ramjet

Excellent expansion tests. I had several 10mm revolvers I used moon clips they were just quicker. Just need to make sure they do not get bent. What I found with my S&W was it liked lighter bullets than it did heavy bullets as far as accuracy. The reason I decided to part with them is because I like my 1911 and Glock 10mm allot more than a handgun and I already have 44mag revolver so no real need. That said it?s a good caliber for revolver and many custom iterations out there that are intriguing.

RJM52

Hope you are still enjoying your new 10mms...have you added any more to the stable...

As to 610 vs GP-100...main reason I went with a 4" GP-100 is size...  I have a ton of S&W .41 Magnums and another N-frame .40 cal just wasn't needed.

Have three GP-100s, 10mm MC, 4" stainless .327 and another 4" in .357 Magnum...  The triggers on both the .327 and 10mm are very good but the one on the .357 is EXCELLENT. All are dead stock factory.

Bob

FreeMe

The trigger on my GP100 Match Champion is very good - as good as any S&W revolver I've had. And accuracy has been good as well,
so far favoring heavier loads. Most accurate load I've found yet has been the Doubletap 230gr cast FP at about 1100 fps.


New to reloading? Get a great kit for a great price today!

Using this link at Amazon for your purchase helps the forum out with small commission. Your price and Amazon benefits stay the same!

Start shooting more today (cause you won't actually save)