Is a 200 gr. TOO heavy for home defense?

Started by Buckeye 50, October 27 2013 09:26:23 AM MDT

Previous topic - Next topic

Buckeye 50

Just so you know, in the event the one in 100,000 event ever does happen in my home, I could care less about over penetration.  I am thinking about overall devastation first, second, third.....

Pat
"Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe to assure the survival and the success of liberty."

John F. Kennedy

Intercooler

You mean like an XTP 200gr? It takes a good bit of speed to really get it to expand well. The sweet spot looks like about 1250-1300 FPS  :o

The_Shadow

It maybe for an apartment dwellers, where pass through of the bullet could possibly escape sheetrock walls and possibly hit the people next door.  However in such a confined location, using faster expanding bullets at less energy or a lesser caliber is more appropriate.  I suppose the same could be said for open public altercations.  However in such a panicked state a total miss is more likely!  :o

You can never be too careful with any weapon.
I am impressed by the guards he built into the slingshot to protect his hands and fingers. But you can never be too careful with a weapon as you will see.  Watch till the end... :-\

http://www.liveleak.com/ll_embed?f=24113d89dfd8
The "10mm" I'm Packin', Has The Bullets Wackin', Smakin' & The Slide is Rackin' & Jackin'!
NRA Life Member
Southeast, LoUiSiAna

Intercooler


LeMat

Man, those head wounds bleed somethin' awful!
This situation is exactly like 1994 and 2009.  Shooters responded emotionally to some threat that did not exist.  Some persons who wanted to appear "in the know" or "connected" used the internet forums to repeat these "sky is falling" rumors over and over until people believed i

4949shooter


pacapcop

All depends on surrounding environment/dwelling.

Mike_Fontenot


I can see the argument for the need for lots of penetration, if the objective is to maximize the chances of a one-shot immediate incapacitation ... in the absence of a head shot, that means the bullet has to reach the spinal column, which is very near the back surface of a human.  And the bullet doesn't just have to penetrate almost the entire torso, it has to still have plenty of energy remaining when it reaches the spine, if it's going to be able to break through the bone.  What that says to me is that any bullet which doesn't hit any bone will necessarily then be a "through-and-through", with only a fraction of the bullet energy being expended in the target.  I think that's just the price that must be paid to get a one-shot immediate incapacitation.