10mm-Auto

General => General Discussion => Topic started by: Overkill338 on July 07 2017 08:38:52 PM MDT

Title: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Overkill338 on July 07 2017 08:38:52 PM MDT
I've got a 3.8" 9x25 Dillon barrel now and I love it. Underwood 124 XTPs I got an average of 1541 from a friend's chrono. Accuracy and fit is great with the LWD barrel. I can rapid fire it a lot easier with the 9x25, and that's still in the 650 ft/lbs neighborhood. I have complete confidence in these XTP's. 16" average penetration through denim. I'd say a few of these might shut down a bad guys pump station.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Olgo on July 09 2017 07:28:29 PM MDT
Told ya.  :D
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: gandog56 on July 12 2017 10:58:57 AM MDT
If you wanted a semi-auto .357 magnum, why not just get a Coonan?
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Olgo on July 12 2017 01:19:08 PM MDT
Because with his G29 he can shoot 10mm, 40sw, 357sig and 9x25 Dillon with the conversion barrels.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Pablo on July 12 2017 01:30:56 PM MDT
Quote from: gandog56 on July 12 2017 10:58:57 AM MDT
If you wanted a semi-auto .357 magnum, why not just get a Coonan?

I actually would love one. But rimmed cartridge and round limited. Plus they need to  make a 9x25 conversion barrel for the 10mm Coonan.  ;D
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Overkill338 on July 12 2017 03:55:46 PM MDT
I put a 357 sig in the barrel and it centers up. I think I can shoot 357 sig from the 9x25 barrel just like 40's from the 10mm barrel.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Olgo on July 12 2017 03:57:44 PM MDT
No you can't. The shoulder on the 357sig is shorter and the case mouth will open up.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Overkill338 on July 12 2017 08:24:31 PM MDT
I said it would shoot not that it would survive. 9x25 vs 9x23
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Olgo on July 13 2017 03:33:40 AM MDT
I get it. May work in a pinch if needed to.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: gandog56 on July 13 2017 08:21:31 AM MDT
Ok, a 357 SIG is basically a .40 cal necked down to 9mm, You even use the same mags and springs, only a barrel swap is required. how about a Super Sig, with a 10mm necked down to 9mm? Oh wait, that is basically a 9X25 Dillon.

Then of course, there is this:
QuoteWhat finally put an end to the 9×25mm Dillon in competition was component wear, magazine capacity and lowering of the USPSA Major power factor from 175 to 165 (160 for IPSC competition). Barrels and compensators in high-pressure cartridges like .38 Super at Major velocities have a much shorter service life than lower-pressure ones. For maximum-permitted length magazines as used in USPSA/IPSC competition, a .38 Super magazine holds more rounds than a 9×25mm Dillon magazine. With the lowering of the USPSA power factor, safety and effectiveness of .38 Super loads improved to a point that the 9×25mm Dillon was no longer competitive and once worn out, pistols were often retired or rebuilt in .38 Super.

So wear and tear could be a problem with 9X25.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: sqlbullet on July 13 2017 09:50:17 AM MDT
Pressure and heat are what wear out barrels fast.  Recoil impulse is what wears out the rest of the gun.

So, yeah, a 9X25 loaded full house is going to wear out faster than a 357 Sig or a 38 Super.  But, a 9X25 loaded to 38 super velocities will last just as long, if not a bit longer than a 38 super/357 Sig.  Depends on if the barrel of the gun wears out first.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Pablo on July 13 2017 10:50:21 AM MDT
If you are shooting 9x25 enough to wear a gun out, can we be friends?
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Olgo on July 13 2017 10:52:18 AM MDT
Quote from: Pablo on July 13 2017 10:50:21 AM MDT
If you are shooting 9x25 enough to wear a gun out, can we be friends?

LOL! The 9x25 conversion barrel for my G29 has a thick barrel so it'll last quite a while.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Overkill338 on July 13 2017 02:28:48 PM MDT
They are thick, here's the end you don't want to be looking at if you're an intruder at 3am.

I'm moving to a 21# spring anyway for my Nuked 10mm's, so component wear will be brought under control also. But so far I have no frame battering after 80 rounds of Underwood's 124gr XTPs.

[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: my_old_glock on July 18 2017 11:51:38 AM MDT


Quote from: Overkill338 on July 12 2017 03:55:46 PM MDT
I put a 357 sig in the barrel and it centers up. I think I can shoot 357 sig from the 9x25 barrel just like 40's from the 10mm barrel.

I don't think it will work. I am guessing the case will open up to 10mm case diameter before the bullet can move into the bore. Once the case no longer can hold the bullet in line with the barrel, the bullet will just flop around in the chamber, and may eventually get forced into the bore sideways.

Place an empty 40S&W case next to an empty 9x25 Dillon case. If the end of the 40 case does not reach the necked down part of the 9x25 case, I doubt a 357 SIG case, which is slightly longer, will hold the bullet.


Quote from: gandog56 on July 13 2017 08:21:31 AM MDT
Ok, a 357 SIG is basically a .40 cal necked down to 9mm, You even use the same mags and springs, only a barrel swap is required. how about a Super Sig, with a 10mm necked down to 9mm? Oh wait, that is basically a 9X25 Dillon.
...

357 Long Neck (Kayan). You can use heavy cast bullets.

http://10mm-firearms.com/wildcats/357-sig-long-neck/


.


.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Overkill338 on July 18 2017 05:12:23 PM MDT
Quote from: my_old_glock on July 18 2017 11:51:38 AM MDT


Quote from: Overkill338 on July 12 2017 03:55:46 PM MDT
I put a 357 sig in the barrel and it centers up. I think I can shoot 357 sig from the 9x25 barrel just like 40's from the 10mm barrel.

I don't think it will work. I am guessing the case will open up to 10mm case diameter before the bullet can move into the bore. Once the case no longer can hold the bullet in line with the barrel, the bullet will just flop around in the chamber, and may eventually get forced into the bore sideways.

Place an empty 40S&W case next to an empty 9x25 Dillon case. If the end of the 40 case does not reach the necked down part of the 9x25 case, I doubt a 357 SIG case, which is slightly longer, will hold the bullet.


Quote from: gandog56 on July 13 2017 08:21:31 AM MDT
Ok, a 357 SIG is basically a .40 cal necked down to 9mm, You even use the same mags and springs, only a barrel swap is required. how about a Super Sig, with a 10mm necked down to 9mm? Oh wait, that is basically a 9X25 Dillon.
...

357 Long Neck (Kayan). You can use heavy cast bullets.

http://10mm-firearms.com/wildcats/357-sig-long-neck/


.


.

I wrote an article on 357 SIG, and in my research I found its based off the 10mm.The 357 SIG has 23mm brass, the 40 uses 22mm.

Edit:I see you mentioned that too, I missed it the first time around.

My dumb ass has already fired a 357Sig in it, and my son was supposed to keep his eyes on the brass, but lost it. I haven't found it yet, my 29 has never behaved as well as my Ruger P93DC , it's mischievous and throws brass every which way, my Ruger will pile them up neatly, about 10 feet over, at a 45 degree angle from me.

I usually recover 4 to 5 out of 11 fired.

[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: my_old_glock on July 20 2017 09:48:07 AM MDT
Quote from: Overkill338 on July 18 2017 05:12:23 PM MDT
...

My dumb ass has already fired a 357Sig in it, and my son was supposed to keep his eyes on the brass but lost it. I haven't found it yet, my 29 has never behaved as well as my Ruger P93DC , it's mischievous and throws brass every which way, my Ruger will pile them up neatly, about 10 feet over, at a 45-degree angle from me.

I usually recover 4 to 5 out of 11 fired.


From what I can see in the picture, it looks like the 357 SIG brass will still hold the bullet in line with the bore if it is fired in a 9x25 Dillon barrel.

Did the bullet come close to what you were aiming at?



.
Title: Re: My semi auto 357 Magnum
Post by: Overkill338 on July 20 2017 07:29:43 PM MDT
It sure did. Just not as loud as the 9x25.