10mm-Auto

General => General Discussion => Topic started by: Tomcat 10 on October 18 2015 09:53:29 AM MDT

Title: What Brass is Good ?
Post by: Tomcat 10 on October 18 2015 09:53:29 AM MDT
 I read a thread some where   about some 10mm brass was not good to reload . There was a head stamp  list of good , and not so good brass . I haven't been able to find that thread .  Does anyone know about this thread ?

   TIA
Title: Re: What Brass is Good ?
Post by: The_Shadow on October 18 2015 10:16:17 AM MDT
Brass that can be questionable are PPU and Armscor AUSA.  They have been successfully reused but some have been a "NO_GO"!

I was sent some PPU stuff that was reloaded by a company, where the bullets had setback into the casings.  Testing showed they would not hold their resized dimensions.  After I did a crude annealing and resized them they did hold better sizing.  Therefore the brass seemed to be stiff/brittle/work hardened... 

Others experienced a casing blowout, which could have resulted in higher pressure form the bullet being set back.  This overpressure blowout also caused the frame of his pistol to crack.

Be sure you test the case to bullet tension for bullet movement, if they seat so easily that the seem to just slide in, they are probably too loose.  :o
Title: Re: What Brass is Good ?
Post by: sqlbullet on October 18 2015 10:40:13 AM MDT
Shadow nailed it.  Starline brass is so cheap, I would suggest you just backorder 1K and call it good.
Title: Re: What Brass is Good ?
Post by: tommac919 on October 18 2015 11:01:03 AM MDT
Starline has in stock now, $162 pr K, free shipping.

good stuff!
Title: Re: What Brass is Good ?
Post by: Tomcat 10 on October 18 2015 11:34:55 AM MDT
Shadow , Thank you very much for your help .  I have some brass from ammo I bought , Remington (UMC) ,PMC , Hornady , and Winchester .  I didn't know if any of them would be on the bad list .
Title: Re: What Brass is Good ?
Post by: Hermit on October 18 2015 01:22:33 PM MDT
Quote from: The_Shadow on October 18 2015 10:16:17 AM MDT
Brass that can be questionable are PPU and Armscor AUSA.  They have been successfully reused but some have been a "NO_GO"!

I was sent some PPU stuff that was reloaded by a company, where the bullets had setback into the casings.  Testing showed they would not hold their resized dimensions.  After I did a crude annealing and resized them they did hold better sizing.  Therefore the brass seemed to be stiff/brittle/work hardened... 

Others experienced a casing blowout, which could have resulted in higher pressure form the bullet being set back.  This overpressure blowout also caused the frame of his pistol to crack.

Be sure you test the case to bullet tension for bullet movement, if they seat so easily that the seem to just slide in, they are probably too loose.  :o

Iv had good luck outta armscor...so far id say several of them have atleast 5 or more of my plinker loads(9-9.2 of longshot at 1.250) on them plus original firing. Still going strong and wet tumbled at that.
Title: Re: What Brass is Good ?
Post by: sstewart on October 19 2015 04:53:19 PM MDT
I would put PPU in the take it to the metal recycling company category.