10mm-Auto

10mm Ammuntion => Reloading 10mm ammo => Topic started by: Huntchick on May 24 2023 08:18:50 AM MDT

Poll
Question: If you could only have one weight XTP for everything what would it be ?
Option 1: 155 grain votes: 1
Option 2: 180 grain votes: 5
Option 3: 200 grain votes: 2
Title: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on May 24 2023 08:18:50 AM MDT
What's your favorite all around choice and what do you use each weight for if you use more than one weight XTP.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on May 24 2023 08:21:12 AM MDT
I'm in the Heavy for Caliber camp myself. Heavy and slow vs light and fast. 200 grain XTP.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: blaster on May 24 2023 11:40:33 AM MDT
my 10mm pistols are for hunting so I like the 200 gr. bullets. I do shoot a lot of 180 gr. cast bullets for practice but that's because I can't find an affordable 200 gr. bullet mold.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: sqlbullet on May 24 2023 01:01:37 PM MDT
Generally 180 grain.  If I need a harder punch I switch to cast bullets for the heavier weights.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on May 24 2023 02:40:52 PM MDT
Awesome gentlemen.
I now in 10mm carry the Montana 200 gr WFN-GC or 200 gr XTP. I?m working on a load using a 180 gr Bayou TC bullet load for general nothing bigger than a black bear. Before Getting into the 10mm I was carrying around a Casul but mostly used 45 long colt in it. Love the gun but just too much to carry anymore. The 10mm has replaced my 357 now. Thanks again for your input.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Kenk on May 24 2023 07:09:08 PM MDT
The XTP 180 has done well for whitetail
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on May 25 2023 05:05:54 AM MDT
Thanks KenK.
So far I've not heard anyone speak on the 155 grain. Honestly I've never really considered it myself. I'm guessing its mostly used as a CCW bullet for 2 legged threats ?
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: blaster on May 25 2023 06:44:54 AM MDT
just guessing here but I would think that a 155 gr. hollow point would open up too quickly and lack the penetration for anything larger than humans or small whitetails.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on May 25 2023 06:57:26 AM MDT
I agree Blaster, I just have not been really able to think of a good reason to use a 155 grain in a 10mm. Not even for Humans especially if dressed heavily.  Maybe Dog or Coyote. I Just Think a 180 or 200 will do everything better, but i could be wrong.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Alabusa on May 27 2023 11:21:45 AM MDT
155gr XTPs are brutal on hogs and deer. I have a nuclear load that is use and is laser accurate to 50 yards which is my personal limit.

Sent from my SM-S918U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on May 27 2023 01:50:28 PM MDT
That?s great information Alabusa. A high speed 155 grain bullet I?m sure causes some serious damage.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Markwell on May 28 2023 10:52:27 AM MDT
     I too go with 200 grr XTPs or 200gr WFN-GC hard cast running a bit over 1200 fps. Used to carry a 5" model 29 with 300gr LBTs in big bear country but the recoil just got to be too much for good double action shooting so we switched to a 10mm 1911 several years ago and haven't looked back.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on June 05 2023 07:30:22 AM MDT
I'm really quite surprised that so many are using 155 gr XTP and so many voted 180 vs 200. But being new to 10mm I've got plenty to learn and appreciate everyone  here willing to share and help.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: blaster on June 05 2023 12:50:22 PM MDT
you came to the right place for all kinds of 10mm info! I have learned a LOT here!
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Kenk on June 05 2023 03:22:26 PM MDT
Absolutely, with tons more to learn
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on June 06 2023 05:57:19 AM MDT
Like everything, always more to learn. One thing I've seen with 10mm vs other firearms and hand / reloading is the desire to push for highest velocities more than any other caliber I've ever dealt with. I'm pretty basic in my approach looking for top 1/4 load data velocities but most importantly for me is accuracy, be that a rifle or handgun. In 10mm I'm happy if i can get ballpark of 1150-1200fps from 200gr. and 1250-1300 from 180 grain. currently a couple of the loads I've found are for my pistol but not recommended for anyone else.

180 XTP 9.0 Longshot
180 coated cast 8.4 longshot
200 WFN-GC  12.5   A#9
200 XTP     12.7  A#9
200 XTP    longshot  TBD?
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on June 06 2023 06:11:31 AM MDT
I'm going to attempt to post picture of the 180 xtps and 180 cast coated. 25 yards off hand at an indoor range a guy i know from old Marine corps days manages. It was a rain day so had to shoot someplace indoors. 
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on June 06 2023 06:17:17 AM MDT
Ok so without some kinda 3rd party photo bucket etc. cant post the pics as an attachment here, sorry. 180 xtp's were 4 touching and 1 about 1" off the 4. The 5  180 cast coated were about an 1 1/2 with 1 i tossed. ugh. pretty much the same with the WFN-GC also.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: blaster on June 06 2023 01:47:07 PM MDT
don't feel rained on. I can't post pictures here either.
as far as the push for velocity in the 10mm, for me anyway he 10mm is magnum revolver performance in a semi auto handgun.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Kenk on June 06 2023 05:28:31 PM MDT
Evening Huntchick, I understand you would like to avoid using 3 party methods to shrink photos that work on this forum, but give this a try if you like, it seem complicated, but it?s really not, plus it?s free. Go to https://postimages.org Once there, click on / select the drop down ?Do Not Resize This Image?, which will give you several options, choose 640 x 480 (For Message Boards) leave the box below ?No Expiration? as is unless you feel the need to change it. Now, click / select ?Choose Images? you will be given 3 options. On my mobile device, I choose ?Photo Library? and your pictures folder will appear. Now tap / click your desired photo and an ?Add button, will appear, tap / click.Add. Once selected, you will have 9 options, click on the very far right  of the 3ed from the bottom ?Hot link for Forums? when you click that, the word ?copy? will appear in blue, now, click / touch a blank area in the post you are creating or responding to, and  select paste, at that point, your photo URL will appear in your post / reply post

Ken
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on June 07 2023 06:44:53 AM MDT
Little rain never hurts. sometimes helps. LoL.
I may try your advise Kenk. It does seem bit drawn out process and I'm not exactly Bill Gates daughter or anything when comes to computers. Ill look into it though. Thanks.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: sqlbullet on June 07 2023 07:07:11 AM MDT
Huntchick there is usually some kind of photo editor included in the base OS of your device. No need to resort to a third party app.

Assuming you are using Windows:  https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/edit-photos-and-videos-in-windows-a3a6e711-1b70-250a-93fa-ef99048a2c86

If you are using MacOS you can use the Preview app in the Applications folder.

If you are on mobile device, the included Photos application usually includes the ability to do basic cropping and resizing.

Hope this helps.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Huntchick on June 07 2023 07:19:45 AM MDT
Thanks appreciate it. Ill see what i can do when i get a chance.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Reloader762 on June 30 2023 06:30:20 AM MDT
Test load I shot out of my Hi Point 10 MM carbine this past weekend, hit the load on the first try.

(https://i.imgur.com/0r9Hqnv.jpg)

Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Kenk on June 30 2023 10:20:01 AM MDT
Nice job. It?s evident your a better shot than I am, but with my 1095TS, 2-3? groups at say 30 yards are constant using 180gr XTP?s and 10.4gr Blue Dot
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: John A. on March 27 2025 02:48:30 PM MDT
I know that the common consensus is fat and slow.  And I'm good with that.  Most of the time, I'm shooting 175 Lee (hard) cast or 180 gr jacketed.

But with that said, the load that I worked up for deer hunting in mind, I use the 155 gr because it is nothing short of amazing.  I'm using the no. 9 powder, 155 hornady xtp and in my gun (carbine barrel) and it's just impressive to me.

I'm getting around 1770 fps out of them.  That's a whopping 1078 foot pounds of energy.  That's more energy at the muzzle than a 223 at 2950 fps.

Also, I don't hunt long ranges.  Most of the shots that I would see are within 50'ish yards or less.  With any luck, half of that from my tree stand.  So I'm not worried as much about bullet drop or energy loss at long ranges.  The increased velocity and energy out of my barrel makes up for it in my opinion.

Compared to 180 gr bullets which can get around 1550 fps out of my barrel.  And 960 ftlbs of energy at the muzzle.  neither loads are wimpy or skimpy.

While some claim they'd never use less than 180 gr bullet to hunt with, realistically, that 155 bullet is only .057th of an ounce lighter.  Yep.  You read that right.  Well less than the weight of a modern dime.

If anyone would like to claim that an animal is really going to know the difference between the two, at the distances that I tend to shoot, that's going to be a very interesting conversation that we can have about it.

My camping loads are generally 175 gr hardcast though.  Mostly for big bears.  Big cats.  Sasquatch.  Haints.
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: The_Shadow on March 27 2025 03:29:57 PM MDT
I hear ya John A.  Hornady makes great bullets for the 10mm/40 cal.
There are some Barnes TAX-XP that would do some good work as well.

I really need to get my new Bear Creek Arsenal 10mm carbine out and run some various ammo through it to see how things work out!  It's a neat carbine with a 16" BBL

(https://i.postimg.cc/44YjJ1Dr/10-mm-16-parkerized-government-barrel-r-cr9179n-jpg.webp) (https://postimages.org/)
Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: John A. on March 27 2025 04:31:39 PM MDT
Yeah, that's why I wanted the carbine. The one I made is light.  Makes for a dandy woods and brush gun.

The 10mm can really shine with a 16" barrel with the right powder and bullet choice. 

Realistically, I like the hardcast better due to the whole "two holes are better than one" that many don't get while using HP's, but if it's not broke.....

Title: Re: Go to choice for XTP bullets
Post by: Ramjet on March 28 2025 06:48:40 AM MDT
I run a Mechtech upper on my Glock 20 and the accuracy is astounding with 200 grain WFN GC PC Cast bullets. But as far as XTP in the 10 lighter and faster is what I prefer. That said the cost on these projectiles is ridiculous. This is why I cast my own and load my own. When you run a WFN hard it doesn't need to expand I have taken many deer with this combination with great success. Handguns and the XTP though light weight drive them hard.