10mm-Auto

General => Questions/Suggestions => Topic started by: Kenk on January 28 2021 06:49:17 PM MST

Title: Froglube paste
Post by: Kenk on January 28 2021 06:49:17 PM MST
Evening, any thoughts on Froglube paste? A buddy of mine sent me a complimentary container of this yesterday to test out

Ken
Title: Re: Froglube paste
Post by: sqlbullet on January 29 2021 08:04:32 AM MST
IIRC it's coconut oil.

Not saying that it is therefore bad, but I am pretty sure the lab tests showed that is what it is.
Title: Re: Froglube paste
Post by: Kenk on January 29 2021 08:36:34 AM MST
Thanks, I have read a number of reviews and many speak very highly of it. If it's actually any good, that remains to be seen

Ken
Title: Re: Froglube paste
Post by: sqlbullet on February 01 2021 08:02:05 AM MST
Most of the bad press comes from forums, not from reviewers.  That could be market at work (people don't usually get paid to say bad things about a product) or it could be a couple of disgruntled users that are sounding off.

Thinking about it and reading the Frog Lube instructions, while knowing that it is a vegetable oil, it makes me think of seasoning a cast iron or carbon steel skillet.  I like to cook and long ago learned how to season a skillet.  Teflon and other modern coatings don't hold a candle to the quality of the crust you can form on a steak in a properly seasoned iron or steel skillet.

But...If you over-oil the skillet during the seasoning process you get a gummy, unusable mess that has to be removed.  I would imagine that with Frog lube you are effectively seasoning the steel parts of your gun.  That is applying a thin coating of oil that will polymerize in heat.  Extending this analogy, the problem most people have when seasoning a skillet is the over-oil it.  Success with skillets comes when you think you have removed the 'excess' oil and then you wipe it one last time with a dry paper towel.

I would be very curious to know how a steel gun would handle a traditional "seasoning" cycle.  Apply a light coat of oil, heat to 300° for an hour and let cool.  This temp is well below the annealing range of carbon steel (550°F-750°F) and is the same cure temperature and time as Cerakote.  I have a CZ-75 that is quite ugly waiting for a refinish.  Perhaps I will parkerize and then "season" it to see what I get.